mises.org/library/isaiah-berlin-negative-freedom

One of the best-known and most influential present-day treatments of liberty is that of Sir Isaiah Berlin. In his Two Concepts of Liberty, Berlin upheld the concept of "negative liberty"—absence of interference with a person's sphere of action—as against "positive liberty," which refers not to liberty at all but to an individual's effective power or mastery over himself or his environment.

Superficially Berlin's concept of negative liberty seems similar to the thesis of the present volume: that liberty is the absence of physically coercive interference or invasion of an individual's person and property. Unfortunately, however, the vagueness of Berlin's concepts led to confusion and to the absence of a systematic and valid libertarian creed.

One of Berlin's fallacies and confusions he himself recognized in a later essay and edition of his original volume. In his Two Concepts of Liberty, he had written that "I am normally said to be free to the degree to which no human being interferes with my activity. Political liberty in this sense is simply the area within which a man can do what he wants."1 Or, as Berlin later phrased it, "In the original version of Two Concepts of Liberty I speak of liberty as the absence of obstacles to the fulfillment of a man's desires."2 But, as he later realized, one grave problem with this formulation is that a man can be held to be "free" in proportion as his wants and desires are extinguished, for example by external conditioning. As Berlin states in his corrective essay,

If degrees of freedom were a function of the satisfaction of desires, I could increase freedom as effectively by eliminating desires as by satisfying them; I could render men (including myself) free by conditioning them into losing the original desires which I have decided not to satisfy.3

In his later (1969) version, Berlin has expunged the offending passage, altering the first statement above to read: "Political liberty in this sense...

Tap to copy the Short Url to this post:
bto.sh/b529g9fs 
All Business News on a Single Page. Join for Free →